Where does the inquiry go?
Someone fills out the contact form on your website. Where does it land? Who sees it? How long until a person replies? And if they don't book a call, does anyone follow up?
For a lot of firms, the honest answers are: a shared inbox, whoever checks it, a day or two, and no.
That's not a character flaw. It's a process gap. And it's one of the cheapest problems in a firm to fix.
What the research says about speed
The best-known study is "The Short Life of Online Sales Leads" in Harvard Business Review. Harvard Business School's summary describes two findings:
- Among 2,241 small and midsize U.S. companies sent a test inquiry, 37% responded within an hour, 24% took more than a day, and 23% never responded at all.
- In a companion study, companies that responded within an hour were about 7 times more likely to reach a key decision-maker than those that waited longer, and 60 times more likely than those that waited more than 24 hours.
Two cautions. That research is from 2011, and it isn't specific to accounting. A business owner choosing a CPA may be more patient than someone shopping for software. Still, the pattern makes sense. A person who just reached out is thinking about their problem now, and may have contacted more than one firm.
Why firms are slow
- Nobody owns intake. "Info@" belongs to everyone, so it belongs to no one.
- Tax season crowds everything out. January to April, new inquiries wait.
- There's no plan for "not yet." Plenty of prospects aren't ready until after the deadline or year-end. Without a follow-up plan, they forget you.
A follow-up standard you can actually keep
- Route every inquiry to a named person. Forms, calls, and chats all go to one place, with one owner and a backup.
- Confirm instantly. An automatic reply thanks them, says when they'll hear from a person, and offers a booking link.
- Reply personally within one business hour. A short, human note is enough.
- Ask a few qualifying questions. Individual or business, industry, rough size, services needed, timing. This helps you prioritize and kindly refer out poor fits.
- Follow up more than once. If they don't book, a few short, helpful touches over two weeks is reasonable. Then stop.
- Keep a "not yet" list. Send prospects who aren't ready an occasional useful update, and check in when they said the timing would be better.
One caution: speed matters, but it never replaces your client acceptance process. Conflict checks, independence considerations, and engagement letters still come first.
Where automation helps, and where it doesn't
Tools can handle the instant confirmation, scheduling, reminders, and "not yet" emails. An AI assistant on your site can answer basic questions after hours and book calls. What shouldn't be automated is judgment: whether you can take the client, what you'll charge, and any advice.
The takeaway
You don't need more leads if you're not answering the ones you have. Name an owner, reply within an hour, and follow up more than once.
If you'd like help mapping what happens to your inquiries today, book a free 30-minute strategy session with Ascend Media. We'll trace one inquiry from form to first conversation.
FAQ
How fast should an accounting firm respond to a new inquiry?
Within an hour during business hours is a sensible standard. Research on online inquiries found responses within an hour were far more likely to reach a decision-maker.
Should we use a CRM?
If inquiries are getting lost, yes. Many practice management platforms include basic CRM features. Pick the one your team will actually use.
How many times should we follow up?
A few helpful touches over about two weeks, then move them to an occasional update list.
Can AI handle intake for a CPA firm?
It can handle confirmations, basic questions, and scheduling. Acceptance decisions and advice should stay with your professionals.
